Saturday, November 8, 2003
Shirky on the Semantic Web

Clay Shirky writes on the semantic web, explaining syllogism (a form of logic, first described by Aristotle, where "...certain things being stated, something other than what is stated follows of necessity from their being so" ), and providing the big picture, concluding that: "Much of the proposed value of the Semantic Web is coming, but it is not coming because of the Semantic Web. The amount of meta-data we generate is increasing dramatically, and it is being exposed for consumption by machines as well as, or instead of, people. But it is being designed a bit at a time, out of self-interest and without regard for global ontology. It is also being adopted piecemeal, and it will bring with it with all the incompatibilities and complexities that implies. There are significant disadvantages to this process relative to the shining vision of the Semantic Web, but the big advantage of this bottom-up design and adoption is that it is actually working now."

Emerging Technologies | PermaLink | Comments (1)

One thing I am finding a bit annoying about Shirky pieces is that he likes to thrash the work of people (sometime rightly, sometimes wrongly) but without providing any suggestions or alternatives.

I like people who play devil's advocate and the questioning-guy in the crowd, but for once they too need to come down from that role and suggest things to improve the situation.

Agreed that the work done using semantic data may not always hold up in front of logical reasoning, but if you thrash it so much (look at the number of examples given), at the least provide some helpful suggestion on how to do it right.

Posted by Srijith
Longhorn Architecture

Here. As fascinating a graphic as you ever saw!

Surging US Productivity

WSJ takes a look at why US productivity is growing so rapidly - "The Labor Department reported Thursday that the productivity of the nation's labor force -- defined as output per hour worked by the average U.S. worker in the nonfarm business sector -- rose at a breathtaking annual rate of 8.1% during the third quarter, following a 7% growth rate in the second quarter."


Far more industries are benefiting from the productivity boom than most economists expected. Some had long argued that productivity growth was confined largely to the manufacturing sector, which could harness innovation to achieve greater efficiency in factories. And even within manufacturing -- which makes up just 14% of the nation's output -- it was thought that technology-producing companies were responsible for much of the nationwide gains in productivity. Behind this view: the ability of the semiconductor industry to double the processing speed of computer chips every 18 months.

Much of the service sector, in contrast, was thought to be ailing from a condition called "Baumol's Disease," named after economist William Baumol. When he first wrote about the subject in the late 1960s, Mr. Baumol argued that productivity in large chunks of the service sector tended to rise more slowly than in manufacturing because services required more hands-on activity that machines couldn't replace.

Mr. Baumol noted that a Mozart quartet would always require four musicians to perform and it would always last about as long as the composer originally intended. Lagging productivity, in turn, tended to push costs in services up faster than overall inflation.

While that was certainly true in the late 1960s, it's starting to change now as technological advances allow service companies to do what electricity allowed manufacturers to do nearly a century ago -- wring costs out of their operations by automating processes that used to require time and people.

In one completed in September, Brookings Institution economists Jack Triplett and Barry Bosworth found that service industries ranging from security brokerages to transportation services to law firms experienced sharply improved productivity-growth rates during the late 1990s. Even the health-care sector -- a long and notable laggard -- went from declining productivity between 1987 and 1995 to slight improvement between 1995 and 2001.

"It is the end of Baumol's disease," says Dale Jorgenson, a Harvard economist whose own work has found productivity trends improving in services. He says service companies in finance, retailing and trade have "become much more like factories" in search of inefficiencies that they can use information technology to eliminate. Mr. Baumol himself says computers may be helping services "more than the remainder of the economy," though he adds education and health are still lagging behind.

Why is this all happening now? Erik Brynjolfsson, an economist at M.I.T. who has studied the behavior of individual firms, says U.S. companies made large investments during the 1990s, not only in technology, but also in a search for ways to reorganize themselves and adapt to a changing technological environment. Then, after the profit collapse, he says, executives intensified their efforts to harvest gains from those reorganization efforts. "We are getting the benefits of past investments," he says.


A comment from John Robb on why this growth can be sustained:

1. The higher averages may mean that greater information flow is smoothing the productivity enhancement curve as well increasing the "sharing" of best practices processes across industry segments. That will yield a higher sustainable average over the longer term.

2. A large percentage of this increase in productivity growth is due to advances in information technology. So as Moore's law marches on, we will continue to see this improve. Information technology is also supercharging other technology segments to plunge them onto their own rapid doubling rates.

3. Finally, the infrastructure for sharing information services (SOA and IT dial-tone) is being put in place across industry segments. This will make it possible to more quickly and fully realize the benefits of Moore's law across all industry segements.

Best of 2003

Popular Science has the 10 best innovations/inventions of 2003. Among them: 802.11g and the Mitsubishi MegaView Wall.

Me
Entrepreneur, Mumbai, India, Emergic, Netcore, Internet, IndiaWorld, Sify, IIT-Bombay, ColumbiaUniv ... More [Write to Me]

- MyToday
- Emergic Ecosystem
- Netcore
- Emergic MailServ: Enterprise Messaging
- Emergic CleanMail: Anti-Virus, Anti-Spam
- BlogStreet: Blog Profiles, RSS Ecosystem
- Novatium: Network Computers
- SEraja: The EventWeb
- Rajshri Media: Broadband Portal
- Newsweek on Novatium (Feb 2007)
- Knowledge@Wharton Interview (Oct 2006)
- TIME Asia (Mar 2000)

Free SMS Updates
Indian mobile users can sms START EMERGIC to 9845398453 to get free daily updates on new additions. [To unsubscribe, sms STOP EMERGIC to 9845398453.]
My Writings
Affordable Computing and ICT for Development
India's Digital Infrastructure (May 2007)
Envisioning Tomorrow's World (Mar 2007)
Computing for the Next Billion (Jun 2006)
City Wi-Fi Networks (Apr 2006)
Microsoft Live (Nov 2005)
Internet Tea Leaves (Sep 2005)
Next-Generation Networks (Jul 2005)
Disruptions (Jul 2005)
The Mobile Phone Platform (Feb 2005)
Microsoft, Bandwidth and Centralised Computing (Jan 2005)
Computing for Broadband 101 (Jan 2005)
Tomorrow's World (Nov 2004)
CommPuting Grid (Nov 2004)
Massputers, Redux (Oct 2004)
The Network Computer (Oct 2004)
Reinventing Computing (Aug 2004)
Tech Trends (Jul 2004)
Letter to Arun Shourie (Apr 2004)
As India Develops (Mar 2004)
My Mental Model (Dec 2003)
The Next Billion (Sep 2003)
Transforming Rural India 2 (Jul 2003)
The Discovery of India (Jun 2003)
Transforming Rural India (Mar 2003)
The Rs 5,000 PC Ecosystem (Jan 2003)
Disruptive Bridges (Nov 2002)
India Post: Ideas for Tomorrow (Nov 2002)
Technology's Next Markets (Oct 2002)
Server-based Computing (Jul 2002)
India's Next Decade (Apr 2002)
The Digital Divide (Apr 2002)
The Real Wireless Revolution (Mar 2002)
Envisioning a New India (Jan 2002)
Emerging Technologies, Emerging Markets (Jan 2002)
The Indianised Linux Desktop (Nov 2001)
Mass Market Internet (Nov 2000)

Enterprise Software and SMEs
The Coming Age of ASPs (May 2005)
SMEs and Technology (Oct 2003)
The Death and Rebirth of Email (Aug 2003)
IT's Future (Aug 2003)
Rethinking the Desktop (Sep 2002)
Rethinking Enterprise Software (Jun 2002)
Emerging Enterprises and Emergent Networks (Mar 2002)
Web Services (Nov 2001)
Alt.Software (Oct 2001)
The Intelligent, Real-Time Enterprise (June 2001)
Enterprise Software (Mar 2001)
SME Tech Utility (Feb 2001)
Software and SMEs (Jan 2001)
The Intelligent Enterprise: Integrating CRM, SCM and EIP (Jan 2001)

Information Management
The Emerging Internet (May 2007)
The Now-New-Near Web (Sep 2006)
Mobile Internet (Aug 2006)
Video on the Internet (Jun 2006)
India Internet and Mobile (Feb 2006)
Rethinking Newspapers (Jan 2006)
Web 2.0 (Oct 2005)
The Future of Search (Mar 2005)
Web 2.0 Conference (Oct 2004)
Thinking A New Food Portal (Sep 2004)
Rethinking Search (Jan 2004)
India.com 2.0 (Jan 2004)
The Publish-Subscribe Web (Jun 2003)
Constructing the Memex (May 2003)
RSS, Blogs and Beyond (Feb 2003)
Blogging (Feb 2002)
Harnessing Information (Oct 2001)
News Refinery (May 2001)

Entrepreneurship
When Bad Things Happen (Jan 2007)
Ventures and Capital (Dec 2006)
15 Years as an Entrepreneur (Nov 2006)
Of Blue Oceans and Black Swans (May 2006)
Let's Build a Business (Apr 2006)
The Value of Vision (Mar 2006)
Vision and Worries (Oct 2005)
Bootstrapping a Business (Oct 2005)
India Needs More Entrepreneurs (Aug 2005)
Dotcom Nostalgia (Jun 2005)
When Things Go Wrong (Apr 2005)
My Life as an Entrepreneur (Nov 2004)
An Entrepreneur's Growth Challenge (Sep 2004)
Creating Options (Sep 2004)
From Employee to Entrepreneur (Aug 2004)
A Tale of Two Summers (Aug 2004)
Crucible Experiences (May 2004)
The Company (May 2004)
An Entrepreneur's Attributes (Nov 2003)
An Entrepreneur's Early Days (Sep 2003)
Reflections on Ideas and Entrepreneurship (Jul 2003)
Entrepreneur's Enigmas (Jan 2003)
The Entrepreneur's Delights (Sep 2002)
Life as an Entrepreneur (Oct 2001)
Leadership Lessons from Lagaan (Aug 2001)
Entrepreneurial Learnings (July 2001)
Entrepreneurship (Mar 2001)
The IndiaWorld Story (1997-8)

Abhishek (my son)
Photos
Letter to a Two-Year-Old (Apr 2007)
Father to Son (Apr 2006)
Letter to a 2005 Baby (Jun 2005)
The Making of Abhishek (Jul 2005)

Moreover
Facebook (May 2007)
Doing Education Right (May 2007)
Reflections from a Dubai Trip (Apr 2007)
Creating India's New Cities (Apr 2007)
India's Challenges (Mar 2007)
3GSM 2007 (Feb 2007)
Demo 2007 (Feb 2007)
A Tale of Two Covers (Feb 2007)
3GSM Mumbai (Feb 2007)
2007 Tech Trends (Jan 2007)
The Best of 2006 (Dec 2006)
Best of Tech Talk 2006 (Dec 2006)
Cyworld (Nov 2006)
Two 2.0 Events (Nov 2006)
Two-Sided Markets (Nov 2006)
The Rise of YouTube (Oct 2006)
Gandhigiri (Oct 2006)
Education and Reservation (May 2006)
Four Blog Years (May 2006)
Fooled by Randomness (May 2006)
Blue Ocean Strategy (May 2006)
Revolution on the Roads (Apr 2006)
The MySpace Story (Mar 2006)
A Presentation at PC Forum (Mar 2006)
Extreme Competition (Mar 2006)
3GSM World Congress 2006 (Feb 2006)
DEMO 2006 (Feb 2006)
India Rising (Jan 2006)
2006 Tech Trends (Jan 2006)
The Best of Tech Talk 2005 (Dec 2005)
The Best of 2005 (Dec 2005)
Trains, Planes and Mobiles (Dec 2005)
Peter Drucker: Management's Newton (Nov 2005)
India Empowered (Oct 2005)
Rajasthan Ruminations 2 (Sep 2005)
Building a Better India (Sep 2005)
South Korea's IT839 (Jul 2005)
Shift-Ctrl (Jul 2005)
Best of Future Tech (Feb 2005)
Multi-Model Minds (Feb 2005)
The Best of 2004 (Jan 2005)
On Watching Swades (Jan 2005)
The Best of Tech Talk 2004 (Dec 2004)
India Trends (Dec 2004)
An American Journey (Aug 2004)
Black Swans (Aug 2004)
A Train Journey (Jun 2004)
An Agenda for the Next Government (May 2004)
Two Blog Years (May 2004)
Rajasthan Ruminations (Feb 2004)
Technology and the Indian Elections (Feb 2004)
2003-04 (Dec 2003)
Random Musings (Sep 2003)
Useful Concepts (July 2003)
Dear Non-Resident Indian (July 2003)
Tech's 10X Tsunamis (July 2002)
An Indian in China (Mar 2002)
Disruptive Technologies (Aug 2001)
Innovation (Aug 2001)
Good Books

- My Business Standard columns
- More columns at Tech Samachar

Presentations
- TiE Bangalore (Dec 2004)
- BangaloreIT.com (Nov 2004)
- CIT 2004 (Jan 2004)
- BangaloreIT.com (Nov 2003)
- Pune CSI Open-Source Workshop (Sep 2003)
- Sydney ICT Workshop (Jul 2003)
- Netcore (Mar 2003)
- Emergent Democracy (MP Govt, Feb 2003)
- Vision for Digitally Bridged India (Dec 2002)
- India Post (Nov 2002)
- Open-Source for eGovernance (Oct 2002)
Recent Entries
Archives
BlogStreet
Syndicate
Powered by
Movable Type 2.21


Main - Feedback
© Rajesh Jain